HCSS
  • Home
  • Research
    • Research
      • All Publications
    • Trending Topics
      • China in a Changing World Order
      • Climate & Security
      • Cyber Policy and Resilience
      • Energy & Raw Materials
      • Europe in the Indo-Pacific Hub
      • Hybrid Threats
      • Initiative on the Future of Transatlantic Relations
      • RuBase: Knowledge base on Russia
      • PROGRESS / Strategic Monitor
      • Strategic Stability: Deterrence and Arms Control
    • All Research Topics
      • Defence and International Security
      • Global Power Shifts
      • Governance and International Organization
      • National Security Strategy
      • Technology & Innovation
      • Strategic Monitor
      • Cyber Policy and Resilience
      • The Climate Security Nexus
      • Critical Materials, Minerals and Metals
      • Natural Resources and Food Security
      • Sustainability and the Energy Transition
      • Terrorism Piracy & Crime
      • International Trade and Competition
    • Special Projects
      • Crowds & Machines
      • Energy Storage in Transition
      • Influencing Human Behaviour
      • The Future of European Strategy
      • Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace (GCSC)
      • IMCCS
      • Robotic and Autonomous Systems
      • The New Space Era
      • Water, Peace & Security (WPS)
  • News
    • BNR | De Strateeg
    • Columns
    • Events
    • HCSS Digest
    • Podcasts
  • HCSS Datalab
    • Climate Security Risk Monitor
    • Cyber Arms Watch
    • Dutch Foreign Relations Index
  • Services
    • Strategic Capability gaming
    • Studio HCSS
    • Indo-Dutch Cyber Security School
  • About Us
    • Experts
    • Contact
    • Subscribe to our Newsletter
    • Press & Media Inquiries
    • Jobs & Internships
    • Partners & Clients
    • Global Futures Foundation
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

News

New report: The Seven Sins of Deterrence Assessment

March 16, 2023

Do NATO’s deterrence policies really have an impact on Russian behaviour? As miscalculation fears rise after a Russian fighter jet collides with a US drone over the Black Sea, how do we truly know if we understand our opponent’s signals – and they understand ours? After all, deterrence is not possible if we do not understand each other’s signals: not only must we understand our adversary, but our adversary must also understand us.

Although the logic of deterrence and its real-world applications may appear intuitively simple and elegant, measuring its effectiveness is much more challenging. In fact, deterrence policymakers can be compared to dancers in the dark: they may know their own deterrence moves, but they can only surmise what the intentions of their counterparts are, and how their deterrence measures shape adversarial behaviour. To this end, literature on evaluating deterrence is scarce, and what is available is rife with methodological, theoretical, and empirical inadequacies.

However, the Russian invasion of Ukraine and increased global geopolitical competition has brought deterrence back to the forefront of Western strategic discourse, meaning that measuring its effectiveness has once again become a matter of utmost importance. At the same time, scholars and strategists are contemplating whether and how basic deterrence concepts are holding up when applied to so-called hybrid threats.

Therefore, to fill current research gap and respond to the pressing demand to design effective deterrence policies, this new HCSS report by Tim Sweijs and Mattia Bertolini identifies seven sins of deterrence assessment. The authors subsequently respond to these seven challenges with seven maxims for deterrence assessments. By heeding these maxims listed deterrence analysts can increase the validity of their deterrence assessments and provide policymakers with a toolkit to measure, evaluate, and improve their deterrence strategies based on sound analysis.

Dancing In The Dark – Report Link

Authors: Tim Sweijs & Mattia Bertolini

The research for and production of this report has been conducted within the PROGRESS research framework agreement. Responsibility for the contents and for the opinions expressed, rests solely with the authors and does not constitute, nor should it be construed as, an endorsement by the Netherlands Ministries of Foreign Affairs and Defence.

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail

Experts

Tim Sweijs
Mattia Bertolini

Related News

Related Content

  1. Teer and Sweijs in The Diplomat: If China Attacks Taiwan, What Will Europe Do?
  2. Book review: Deterrence in the 21st Century – Insights from Theory and Practice Book review: Deterrence in the 21st Century – Insights from Theory and Practice
  3. New Snapshot: Preventing the (Un)thinkable: Escalation Scenarios and Risk Reduction Measures for Russia and NATO following the War in Ukraine

Office Address

  • The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies
  • Lange Voorhout 1
  • 2514 EA The Hague
  • The Netherlands

Contact Us

  • Telephone: +31(70) 318 48 40
  • E-mail: info@hcss.nl
  • IBAN NL10INGB0666328730
  • BIC INGBNL2A
  • VAT NL.8101.32.436.B01
  • Contact

Legal & Privacy

  • Disclaimer & Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions (NL) 
  • Terms & Conditions (ENG) 
  • Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure

Follow us

© The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies
    Jeff Amrish Ritoe | Atlantic Assembly 2023: the geopolitical implications of...Nature-based Solutions for Water and Peace | UN Water Week 2023
    Scroll to top

    GDPR Consent

    Your privacy is important to us. Here you can set which consent you are allowing us with regards to the collection of general information, the placing of cookies of the collection of personal information. You can click 'Forget my settings' at the bottom of this form to revoke all given consents.

    Privacy policy | Close
    Settings

    GDPR Consent Settings

    Your privacy is important to us. Here you can set which consent you are allowing us with regards to the collection of general information, the placing of cookies of the collection of personal information. You can click 'Forget my settings' at the bottom of this form to revoke all given consents.

    Website statistics collect anonymized information about how the site is used. This information is used to optimize the website and to ensure an optimal user experience.

    View details

    Functional cookies are used to ensure the website works properly and are neccessary to make the site function. These cookies do not collect any personal data.  

    View details
    Forget my settings Deleted!