HCSS
  • News
    • BNR | De Strateeg
    • Columns
    • Draghi Report Series
    • Events
    • Podcasts
  • Publications
    • Publications
      • All Publications
    • Defence & Security
      • Behavioural Influencing in the Military Domain
      • (Nuclear) Deterrence and Arms Control
      • Hybrid Threats
      • Rethinking Fire and Manoeuvre
      • Robotic and Autonomous Systems
      • Strategic Monitor Dutch Police
      • Transnational Organised Crime
    • Geopolitics & Geo-economics
      • China in a Changing World Order
      • Europe in a Changing World Order
      • Europe in the Indo-Pacific
      • Knowledge base on Russia (RuBase)
      • PROGRESS / Strategic Monitor
      • Transatlantic Relations
    • Climate, Energy, Materials & Food
      • Climate and Security
        • International Military Council on Climate and Security (IMCCS)
        • Water, Peace & Security (WPS)
      • Critical Minerals
      • Energy Security
        • Tank Storage in Transition
      • Food Security
    • Strategic Technologies
      • Cyber Policy & Resilience
        • Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace (GCSC)
      • Emerging Technologies
      • Global Commission on Responsible Artificial Intelligence in the Military Domain (GC REAIM)
      • Semiconductors
      • Space
  • Dashboards
    • Dashboards
      • All Dashboards
        • GINA
    • Defence & Security
      • DAMON | Disturbances and Aggression Monitor
      • GINA | Military
      • Nuclear Timeline
    • Geopolitics & Geo-economics
      • Dutch Foreign Relations Index
      • GINA | Diplomatic
      • GINA | Economic
      • GINA | Information
    • Climate, Energy, Materials & Food
      • Agrifood Monitor
      • CRM Dashboard
    • Strategic Technologies
      • Cyber Arms Watch
      • Cyber Comparator
      • Cyber Norms Observatory
      • Cyber Transparency
  • Services
    • HCSS Boardroom
    • HCSS Datalab
    • HCSS Socio-Political Instability Survey
    • Strategic Capability Gaming
    • Studio HCSS
    • Indo-Dutch Cyber Security School 2024
    • Southern Africa-Netherlands Cyber Security School 2025
  • NATO Summit
  • GC REAIM
    • GC REAIM | Members
    • GC REAIM | Conferences
    • GC REAIM | Partners, Sponsors, Supporters
  • About HCSS
    • Contact Us
    • Our People
    • Funding & Transparency
    • Partners & Clients
    • HCSS Newsletter
    • HCSS Internship Programme
    • Press & Media Inquiries
    • Working at HCSS
    • Global Futures Foundation
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu

News

Column: Don’t knock yourself out: How America can turn the tables on China by giving up the fight for command of the seas

February 23, 2021

US strategy in the Western Pacific is based on a fundamentally flawed premise – that relinquishing control over the maritime commons will necessarily lead to China filling the vacuum. That is the position taken by our Senior Strategic Analyst Paul van Hooft in his latest article in “War On the Rocks”.

According to him, there are several reasons to believe that this premise is flawed. The attempt to secure total US hegemony over the Western Pacific leaves the US vulnerable to the “tyranny of distance” and will therefore overextend US forces. By presenting China as an existential threat to domestic audiences and committing itself to a permanent presence in the Western Pacific, the US is backing itself into a corner. While this naval presence allows US forces to project themselves globally, this tyranny of distance also makes the US vulnerable to measures intended to raise the costs of maintaining such an extensive naval commitment. 

Van Hooft argues that it is cheaper and easier to work with allies to deny China command of the Pacific maritime commons than for the US to claim it for itself. Rather than allowing China to fill the vacuum, a reduced US naval commitment that maintains cooperation with allies would either force China to accept the status quo or break out and overextend itself. Both scenarios deny China exclusive control over the maritime commons.

The focus on a grand strategy aimed at achieving naval dominance plays into China’s hands – it allows China to deploy a cost imposing strategy that forces the US to overextend itself.

Paul van Hooft’s full article can be found here: Don’t Knock Yourself Out: How America Can Turn the Tables on China by Giving Up the Fight for Command of the Seas – War on the Rocks

'The focus on a grand strategy aimed at achieving naval dominance plays into China’s hands.'

In case you missed it: @paulvanhooft's analysis of US strategy in the Western Pacific is one of the most read @WarOnTheRocks articles of 2021:https://t.co/7VZxP5CpHQ

— HCSS – The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies (@hcssnl) December 31, 2021

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail

Experts

Paul van Hooft

Related News

Related Content

Militaire Courant | Column: China, China en nog eens China
Column: China gebruikt westerse zwakte om eigen positie te verstevigen
Column Trouw Rob de Wijk
Column Rob de Wijk: China boeit Biden meer dan Rusland

Office Address

  • The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies
  • Lange Voorhout 1
  • 2514 EA The Hague
  • The Netherlands

Contact Us

  • Telephone: +31(70) 318 48 40
  • E-mail: info@hcss.nl
  • IBAN NL10INGB0666328730
  • BIC INGBNL2A
  • VAT NL.8101.32.436.B01
  • Contact

Legal & Privacy

  • Disclaimer & Privacy
  • Algemene Voorwaarden (NL) 
  • Terms & Conditions (ENG) 
  • Coordinated Vulnerability Disclosure
  • Ethical Standards
  • Manual for Responsible Use of AI

Follow us

© The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies
    Link to: HCSS Digest | Week 7 Link to: HCSS Digest | Week 7 HCSS Digest | Week 7Week 7 - HCSS Digest Link to: Collective Collapse or Resilience? European Defense Priorities in the Pandemic Era Link to: Collective Collapse or Resilience? European Defense Priorities in the Pandemic Era Collective Collapse or Resilience? European Defense Priorities in the Pandemic...
    Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top

    GDPR Consent

    Your privacy is important to us. Here you can set which consent you are allowing us with regards to the collection of general information, the placing of cookies of the collection of personal information. You can click 'Forget my settings' at the bottom of this form to revoke all given consents.

    Privacy policy | Close
    Settings

    GDPR Consent Settings

    Your privacy is important to us. Here you can set which consent you are allowing us with regards to the collection of general information, the placing of cookies of the collection of personal information. You can click 'Forget my settings' at the bottom of this form to revoke all given consents.

    Website statistics collect anonymized information about how the site is used. This information is used to optimize the website and to ensure an optimal user experience.

    View details

    Functional cookies are used to ensure the website works properly and are neccessary to make the site function. These cookies do not collect any personal data.  

    View details
    Forget my settings Deleted!