Research

Grey Zone Guest Paper Series | Grey Zone Activities against Taiwan at Sea: China Coast Guard Operational Pattern Analysis and Strategic Lessons for Small and Middle Powers

What are China’s plans in the waters around Taiwan? And how can other small and middle powers learn from Taiwan’s response to China’s actions? 

Over the years, China has adopted an increasingly aggressive and intrusive stance in the waters surrounding Taiwan. The actions of the Chinese coastguard and maritime law enforcement agencies around Taiwan demonstrate how pressure in the grey zone can gradually reshape the operational environment, without crossing the threshold into open conflict. 

In ‘Grey Zone Activities against Taiwan at Sea’, Po-Jui Huang, Bo-Xiang You, Kuma Yung and Tsaiying Lu analyse recent operations by the Chinese coastguard around Taiwan and draw strategic lessons for small and middle powers. 

‘Taiwan’s experience shows the need to build a basis for combining early recognition, credible public evidence, sustainable surveillance, and coordinated legal action before repeated pressure narrows the options available to governments and maritime users.’

The authors identify three main patterns since 2024: joint exercises with the People’s Liberation Army, ‘normalised’ law enforcement patrols in the waters between Xiamen and Kinmen, and escort operations for scientific research and fishing vessels in the waters east of Taiwan. These activities are aimed at undermining Taiwan’s sovereignty through a sustained presence and the normalisation of Chinese operational claims. 

The authors urge that Taiwan should not be viewed as a separate case. As cooperation between the Chinese and Russian coastguards offers opportunities for operational learning and coordination, Taiwan’s experiences are relevant to European security planning. For other small and middle powers in Europe, the article therefore emphasises that maritime coercion in the Indo-Pacific is not a distant concern. It should therefore not be regarded as a geographically remote issue. It concerns everyone, including Europe. 

Key takeaways:

  • Persistent coast guard operations can normalise an adversary’s presence and erode sovereignty over time. 
  • Grey-zone activity increasingly combines military exercises, law-enforcement operations and civilian-vessel escort missions. 
  • Transparency should be developed as a routine operational capability. 
  • Timely evidence release and access for independent journalists can help counter coercive narratives. 

Authors: Po-Jui Huang, Bo-Xiang You, Kuma Yung and Tsaiying Lu; with the Taiwan Association for Strategic Simulation and DSET.

Quality assurance: Hans Horan and Davis Ellison. 

This guest paper is part of a series that looks at how countries that face hybrid threats navigate through the grey zone, the twilight area between peace and war. Each guest paper looks at a different case (South Korea, Taiwan or Estonia) and offers suggestions for other small to middle powers facing similar threats.

Paper 1 | Estonia’s Preparedness to Counter Russian Hybrid Threats

Paper 2 | Denying Strategic Gains: South Korea’s Conditional Proactive Response to North Korean Grey-Zone Coercion

Paper 3 | Grey Zone Activities against Taiwan at Sea: China Coast Guard Operational Pattern Analysis and Strategic Lessons for Small and Middle Powers

The research for and production of this report has been conducted within the PROGRESS research framework agreement. Responsibility for the contents and for the opinions expressed, rests solely with the authors and does not constitute, not should be construed as, an endorsement by the Netherlands Ministries of Foreign Affairs and Defence.

Experts

© The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies